I've talked about some of my odd room reservation experiences before, and I've learned a lot from them. Primarily, I've learned to book a room the SECOND you so much as CONSIDER going to WDW, a year in advance if possible.
I was smart for this year's Wine & Dine Half weekend, and booked my room at Pop in January. When I decided to extend my races weekend to include the 10K, I was luckily able to cancel my first reservation and re-book with the additional night. That was March.
Two months later, I asked my race weekend buddy Erika if she had booked a room yet. She's a newbie to WDW and runDisney, and she hasn't decided yet if she wants to share a room with me or bring her kids and get her own room. I encouraged her to book a room now just to be safe; she can always cancel later. (For the record, you can cancel a WDW hotel reservation up to a week in advance without penalty. The more you know!)
I promised to send her an email with info about Pop, where I'm staying, as well as some alternatives. A search on the Disney site with our dates found that, six months in advance of arrival, you can stay... practically nowhere.
Certainly no values. Art of Animation has suites, but they're twice as expensive as a regular room. On the moderate level, I've seen Coronado and Caribbean waft in and out of availability - but they're both under construction, so yuck. And then of course you have a smattering of deluxe resorts, but it's mostly only the fancier rooms that are still available, with views and suchlike. I don't run in circles where the people are made of money, so.
For now I've advised Erika to pick up the Art of Animation suite (which wouldn't be the worst to have with two kids). If she wants to stay with me in the end, great; she can cancel. If not, she has a room - and in the meantime she can keep checking back. If her nerves are steely enough, she can probably expect a value to pop up a couple weeks out from check-in day. I've had that luck before.
Remember the good old days, when you could wait until room-only discount offers were released a couple months in advance and casually book then? Yeah. I wouldn't hold my breath for a return to that model any time soon. When Star Wars Galaxy's Edge opens, we better all watch our backs...
What's your Disney hotel reservation strategy? Have you ever been locked out?
Don't forget, you can follow FRoA on Twitter @fairestrunofall. If you have any questions, leave a comment or email firstname.lastname@example.org. See ya real soon!