In Which Jenn Makes A New WDW To-Eat List

Waaaay back in 2014, when this blog was a mere baby blog – a blaby? A blogby? – I did a post about all the foods I wanted to eat at Walt Disney World. Since then, I have made a small dent in that list… and since then, five years’ worth of NEW foods have popped up.

Disney food to eat

So I did it again! I went combing through the last year’s worth of Disney Food Blog archives, painstakingly searching for reviews of foods that looked simply too delicious not to pursue. Any time I found such a wonderful treat, I compiled it in a spreadsheet. (Where would a WDW planner be without spreadsheets?)

There were some criteria, of course. It had to be something I was legit jazzed about, not just “oh, that looks good.” And no seasonal or limited edition items; that’s a recipe for heartache. In my research, I didn’t go back much more than a year to avoid changed or discontinued items. But other than that, all things delectable were fair game!

And so I present to you: my 2019 WDW To-Eat List. I have a lot of work to do.

(Curious to see how I did on my first list? I’ve updated it! Check it out.)





Bubble waffle ice cream

The Polite Pig

Gideon’s cookies


Jalapeno & cheese stuffed pretzel


Marshmallow wand

Nomad Lounge

Tuna poke bowl

Santu’li Canteen

Cheeseburger pods

Dawa Bar

Ngumu Jungle Juice


Thirsty River Bar

Dragon’s Breath

All-Star Sports

Edible cookie dough

Pop Century

Oatmeal cookie sandwich

Rose & Crown

Sticky toffee pudding

Woody’s Lunchbox

Grown-up grilled cheese


Woody’s Lunchbox

Chocolate hazelnut lunchbox tart

Woody’s Lunchbox

S’mores breakfast sandwich


Flourless chocolate cake

Trolley Car Cafe

Peanut butter cupcake (regular or Kylo Ren)

Contempo Cafe

Peanut butter pie

Wine Bar George

Crispy mac ‘n cheese bites


Purple wall slush

Trolley Car Cafe

Carrot cake cookie in its new iteration

Beaches & Cream

Chocolate layer cake

Beaches & Cream

Grilled banana bread with peanut butter

The Ganachery

Homemade s’more

Prime Time Cafe

Peanut butter and jelly milkshake

Cheshire Cafe

Ham and cheese pretzel

Cheshire Cafe

Cheshire cat tail


Adventureland Cart

Cheesburger egg rolls


Pinocchio Village Haus

Italian cream cake

The Smiling Crocodile

Pimento cheese BLT

Jock Lindsey’s

Air pirate pretzels



Mickey scone

The Mara

Peanut butter brownie

Ale & Compass

Parker House rolls and spreads

Kringla Bakery


Nomad Lounge

Jenn’s Tattoo (MINE!)



Frosting shots

Pop Century

King whoopie pie

Plaza Ice Cream Parlor

All-American sundae

House of Blues

Toffee butter bread pudding


Shave ice with condensed milk

Yachstman Steakhouse

Onion pull-apart rolls

Good’s Food To Go

Bread pudding

BaseLine Tap House

Beer flight

Territory Lounge

Cheese fondue


Pepper’s Ghost

Contempo Cafe

Chocolate chip cookie sandwich

Skipper Canteen

Curried vegetable crew stew



Crissy Fields cookie bits sundae

Sunshine Seasons

Red velvet whoopie pie

Pongu Pongu



Top of the World

Chocolate cake

The Mara

Kudu cookies


Kusafiri Bakery

Roast beef & cheddar panini w/ curry chips


Cookie dough flight

African Outpost

Brown Elephant


Troll Kreme Slush


Seared tuna

Tangaroa Terrace

Fried Spam Masubi

All-Star Music

Princess Aurora cupcake

Yorkshire Fish Shop

English meat pie

Have you tried any of the above foods? What’s on your To-Eat list?

Don’t forget, you can follow FRoA on Twitter @fairestrunofall and on Instagram @fairestrunofall. If you have any questions or thoughts, leave a comment or email fairestrunofall@gmail.comSee ya real soon!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>